Oliver Luck’s XFL-related case against Vince McMahon headed to trial

McMahon and Luck
A court will decide if Vince McMahon has to pay out Oliver Luck’s XFL contract.

As per Ben Fischer of Sports Business Journal, jury selection and the trial between ex-XFL Commissioner Oliver Luck and formal league owner Vince McMahon is set to begin on 11 July. The trial, unrelated to the new XFL which was bought out of bankruptcy, is expected to last about one week.

For XFL fans, moving past this legal action will mark the end of an ugly chapter in the history of the league. While the devastating news of XFL 2020 declaring bankruptcy in the aftermath of a coronavirus closure, the news of the rift between the league’s beloved Commissioner and owner was another dagger to the heart.

Basically, Luck wants his contract to be paid, consisting of damages of $15.9M in base salary, $8M in guaranteed bonuses and more in insurance premiums.

Pre-trial legal action has pared down the decision to one point of contention, where McMahon’s legal defense claims Luck acted recklessly, in contravention of order by McMahon to not sign players with criminal charges against them, by signing wide receiver Anthony Callaway to the Tampa Bay Vipers in January 2020. Callaway spent six days on the Tampa Bay Vipers’ roster before sustaining a knee injury in his very first practice.

Callaway’s previous legal problems amounted to a citation issued on 18 August 2018 in Strongsville, Ohio for possession of marijuana and driving with a suspended license during a traffic stop. The drug charges were dropped, and Callaway paid a $911 fine for the license violation.

Aside from the Callaway issue, McMahon’s original defense of the lawsuit claimed Luck had used his company phone for personal matters, abandoned his position at the onset of the pandemic, and disclosed confidential information to his brother-in-law, then-Wasserman Executive Will Wilson. However, a pretrial ruling made by U.S. District Court Judge Victor Bolden dismissed all of McMahon’s defenses except the Callaway matter.

The July court case will boil down to two points. Was the Callaway signing valid cause to fire Oliver Luck, and was there anything Luck could have done to mitigate the issue after it happened?

If the jury finds Luck to be at fault, they might simply find him culpable for the money the league paid Callaway, and restitution could be be paid to correct the mistake. However, McMahon’s attorneys will not be willing to settle this so simply. They will contend that Callaway’s signing damaged the reputation of the league and destroyed trust between McMahon and Luck.

In a pre-trial deposition dated 13 May 2021, Luck’s lawyer Paul Dobrowski questioned McMahon on his own criminal past:

Dobrowski: And, I’m sorry, sir, were you ever criminally charged previous to starting the XFL in 2018?
McMahon: Was I prior to this?
Dobrowski: Yeah.
McMahon: I was and acquitted.
Dobrowski: I didn’t ask if you were acquitted. I asked if you were criminally charged.
McMahon: I was and acquitted.
Dobrowski: What were you criminally charged with?
McMahon: A charge that someone has never been charged with before or since. It was something along the lines of deceiving the FDA in some capacity and things along those lines.
Dobrowski: Okay. And, again, I’m not a criminal lawyer like Mr. McMahon, but was that a felony charge?
McMahon: It would have been, yes.
Dobrowski: And so if a person had your background as a player, would they have been disqualified from being employed by the XFL?
McMahon: If, in fact, someone had been charged with a felony?
Dobrowski: Yeah.
McMahon: If, in fact — yes, they would have been.

Dobrowski: Under your definition of that applied to XFL employees and players particularly, you were not a man of good character, true?
McMahon: As an employer, I would not have been allowed to play.
Dobrowski: But it was okay for you to be the owner, right, with that criminal charge, right?
McMahon: I was the owner.

Lawyers, huh? Hopefully, this fancy legal wrangling will mark the completion of the ugliness that ended XFL’s glorious rise in 2020, and give us a moment to look forward to a greater moment… XFL football in 2023.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.